Haunted Houses
Nightmares, property taxes and Spalding Gray: Why the idea of downsizing both thrills and terrifies me.




I dream in houses. Have for years. And unlike my husband, who thinks of dreams as mere “inflight entertainment” for sleepytime, I take dreams seriously. Maybe because the only times my analyst ever picked up her pen in 15 years of therapy was when I recounted one.
The house, in dreams, represents the self. A well-known fact. The most pleasant of house dreams — a dream Jung himself reported having — is walking around your house and suddenly finding rooms and wings you never noticed before. All representing untapped potential! Undeveloped aspects of the self! I had those dreams for years. Fairytale dreams of dens, attics, bedrooms, offices, arbors and whole courtyards popping up magically, under my very own roof. And voila, didn’t it turn out that I had a successful blog and several novels in me?
But then, about a decade ago, the house dreams changed into nightmares. I began having a recurrent dream in which I’d sold my house, moved and was seized with regret. Usually, in the dream, I’d move yet again, trying vainly to correct the error. But moving only made it worse, as I traded down in a succession of ever-worsening real estate deals. The old house, the one I’d fallen asleep in, was suddenly the sine qua non of my existence. And stupidly, willingly — and of course unconsciously — I’d traded it away. It was always the solidity of the house I missed the most. The sturdiness of its doors. Sometimes the new house I’d moved to would be just down the street, but the loss was just as palpable.
Of course this was the opposite of those happy house dreams of yore. Rather than unrealized potential, the new dreams stood for diminishment. Or at least the fear of diminishment.
I’d wake up, shudder, look around, realize I’d made no fatal real estate transactions overnight, and do my best to ignore whatever my unconscious was trying to tell me.


Flash forward. The house is paid off. We’ve graduated two kids from high school and college. The boomerang child has finally moved out. Our biggest financial asset now sits mostly empty, while the property tax bill has soared to $19,000 a year — and that’s on the low side for my neighborhood. According to Zillow, my county has the second-highest property taxes in the country.
The math alone suggests a change. It feels like leaving the front door open on a snowy day with the heat blasting. Like I’m watching my money seep away.
We have friends, faced with similar math, whose calculations — financial and otherwise — led them to Maine. Their old house was charming but the Maine house surpassed it. They’d left an artsy town with indie bookstores for another artsy town with indie bookstores — plus Celtic festivals, ukulele play-alongs and lobster shacks. They’d pulled off a brilliant piece of real estate arbitrage: selling high, buying low, slashing their taxes. And somehow they’d managed to retain their souls in the bargain.
Thus, after a quarter of a century in one house — a record of stability and inertia — I began to consider the idea of moving.
I started thinking of Maine, of course, where we’d had a pleasant week in July visiting our friends. Then came winter and the certainty that I lacked the capacity for any more than cold weather than I was already enduring in New Jersey. So I started thinking of other places. Miami, Asheville, Charlottesville, Austin. I tested them all out with my husband, often late at night when he was sleeping. He’d grunt indifferently.
Even I knew this wasn’t likely to happen, that we were unlikely to undertake a relocation so radical we’d have to forsake our jobs and our health insurance. Not to mention our friends.
So then, naturally, closer options presented themselves. We went one day with our friend Frank, a realtor, to see a small side-door Colonial a few towns away. It had its charms, and its quirks, and taxes just over half of what we pay. I could picture us living there. It didn’t need much work. It backed into a woods, which meant no back yard to mow. My husband even liked it. After 25 years in the same house, we agreed, moving to a new town would be an adventure. A minor adventure, maybe, but an adventure nonetheless.
Then I ran it by my brother, our family’s resident MBA. Doing a quick mental calculation, he pointed out that, with transaction costs, we wouldn’t save any real money unless we planned to live there at least six years.
“If you love the house, by all means,” he said.
And that’s when I remembered the dreams.


In late April, a remarkable story by Oliver Sacks appeared in the New Yorker. I’ve been a fan of Sacks since the mid-1980s, when my husband had come home with a copy of “The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat” and I’d snatched it out of his hands. When Sacks revealed in February that he had terminal cancer, he came front and center in my consciousness again, making any new piece of writing by him irresistible. Doubly so when it turned out the subject of the New Yorker article was the gifted monologist Spalding Gray, whose body had washed up in the East River in 2004, an apparent suicide.
The movie “Swimming to Cambodia,” based on Gray’s one-man show, came out in 1987, just two years after “The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat.” For a baby boomer with a certain level of erudition, living in New York City in the mid-1980s, both Sacks and Gray were cultural icons. Most of my friends get the New Yorker. Everybody saw the story, and almost everybody had read it.
It turned out that Sacks had been Gray’s neurologist.
The story began with Gray’s car accident in Ireland in the summer of 2001. I don’t remember hearing about it at the time, but my husband did. He reminded me of it when we traveled to Ireland, and I found myself terrified by the narrow twisty roads. The accident, and whatever it did to Gray’s brain, had set off Gray’s downward spiral of depression.
One detail in Sacks’s story leaped out. While Gray was recuperating in an Irish hospital, he decided to sell his house in Sag Harbor— a decision he almost immediately regretted. So much so that on Sept. 11, 2001, the day his family was scheduled to move out of the Sag Harbor homestead, he “barely registered” the attack on the World Trade Center 100 miles west.
“Spalding had been sunk in depressive, obsessive, angry, guilty rumination about selling the house,” Sacks wrote. “Nothing could distract him from it. Scenes and conversations about the house replayed incessantly in his mind. All other matters seemed to him peripheral and insignificant.”
But that wasn’t all. It turned out that Gray’s mother had sold the family home, regretted it deeply, and also committed suicide.
The story felt like a knife to the heart. I had never met anyone else who’d had my dream about real estate regret, let alone heard it manifest into real-life depression and suicide.
I began to fear that I’d never be able to move. Or that if I did, I would never get over it.


Dreams speak symbolically. I know that. I believe my dreams of real estate regret — which have subsided the last few years, by the way — are not meant as actual warnings about real estate. They’re my unconscious telling me to diminish my expectations.
When we’re so young that people ask what we want to be when we grow up, the world literally seems wide open. Teacher? Ballerina? Major league baseball player? Astronaut? Why not?
The options narrow as we enter our 20s, but worldly success still seems possible. And there are still major choices. We have yet to pick a mate. We could live anywhere.
With each decade, the options narrow. We have picked our profession, our mate, our home. By our sixth decade, our children — whose noise and endless school projects distract us from our own mortality — have left the nest.
The branches on our decision trees get narrower and narrower. Eventually, they seem like twigs. Movie or dinner with friends on Saturday night? Or, narrower still, which Netflix movie tonight, Honey?
This, I believe, is the subtext of my recurrent dream.
Yet here I am also, suddenly, confronting the text of the dream as well. Symbolism and real estate are converging. Time is coming to sell the big house. Life, taxes, math are beginning to beg the question. My unconscious just got here a decade before me.


Despite my fears, there’s something inherently fun about house-hunting. It’s like dress-up or playing school when you’re a kid: you get to project yourself into another life. Yes, it can be depressing to traipse around certain properties — places where the curtains and wallpaper recall sad eras in decorating history, or where the wood has been covered with any number of man-made materials — but it can also be exciting.
Just last week, we looked a house in a beach town about an hour away. It’s just feet from the home of one of my closest friends. A sunny, cheerful, unfussy Victorian, it was well-priced — we could buy it with cash after selling ours, and still have a good chunk of change leftover — and again it would cut our taxes in half. It also had an enormous wrap-around porch, something we’ve both fantasized about for years.
In fact, there was nothing wrong with it, nothing at all — except for the fact that it’s a bit too far to commute, a bit too early for us to retire.
The following day, I went to an open hour closer to home. That was a disaster. An estate, it had been unoccupied for more than a year — and big sections of the kitchen and bathroom floor were missing. Clearly the pipes had frozen, and the repairs had been hasty and limited. The walls were stained and the house smelled of must and sadness. Yes, it had potential — for somebody. Not me.
My friend at the beach texted me today to say that there are balloons festooning the house with the wrap-around porch. They’re having an open house. My heart sinks. I want that house, but since I’m not ready to pull the trigger, someone else will get it.
And yet, the very fact of its existence gives me hope. It means that moving from a family-size house to couple-sized one doesn’t have to involve bitter disappointment.
Someday, the math will work.
Someday, we will find our cottage.
Or maybe something else. Just two nights ago, I had another house dream, different from any I’d had before. This time, I was with a group of people in a mansion, and we were all getting an opportunity to pick one of the rooms to live in for the next year. It was a mad dash, like a game of Musical Chairs. Or Pac-Man, because if you ran down a corridor and found a room that someone had already claimed, you had to reverse direction and race to another room.
I got one of the rooms in the dream, and I was delighted, although my husband wasn’t quite convinced he wanted to come with me.
Could this portend a co-living space? Apartment dwelling? Divorce? Or is it a simple reminder that real estate is always a race? If I want the sweet Victorian, or any house of my dreams, I’m going to have to pounce.
But then we know that house dreams are about the self, not real estate. So, is the subtext of the dream competition? Or community? Or is my unconscious so many steps ahead of me that the meaning won’t become clear for years?


Debbie Galant is the founder and publisher of Midcentury Modern, which explores the intersection of age and ideas. Here’s how to follow it: Medium | Facebook | Twitter | Newsletter